He Says Otherwise1 Samuel 16:7

The Machine and the Other Voice

This message is for A woman at a supermarket self checkout listening to two voices at once, the machine's and the one in her own head, who has been treating her running commentary as a report on herself rather than as a voice with a source.

There are eight of them in a row and six are working, and the one on the end has had a laminated sign on it since a week last Tuesday.

She is on number three. Bananas, which need the little search screen and the button for loose items. A box of something that will not scan at all and has to be done twice. Bread. And the machine is talking to her the whole time in that voice they all have, the one designed by somebody who had never met a human being: please place the item in the bagging area. unexpected item in the bagging area. please wait, assistance is on its way.

A young lad with a lanyard comes over, does the thing with his card, says these ones are terrible, and goes again.

And underneath the machine's voice, running the entire time, at a volume nobody else in that shop can hear, is the other one.

The other one is not impersonal. That is the difference. The machine says unexpected item because a weight sensor registered a discrepancy. The other voice says things about her, in her own accent, about who she is and what she is like and what people would think, and it has been doing it since about six that morning, and it has been doing it for a very long time.

She would not read that voice out loud. Not to her sister, not to anybody. Some of it she would not repeat about a stranger.

And if something in you went quiet reading that, I want to talk to you and not around you. Not about the thing under it, whatever that is. I am not going to ask you for it. I want to talk about the voice, and specifically about what kind of thing it actually is, because you have been treating it as a report.

A report has a source, and this one has been unexamined for years

Let me start with the thing I am not going to do.

I am not going to tell you off for it. Self contempt is not pride, whatever you have been told by somebody who meant well, and I am not going to hand you a rebuke on top of a voice that has been rebuking you since breakfast. That would be the cruellest possible response and it is a very common one.

I am also not going to argue with it. You have argued with it for years. You are better at arguing with it than I am, and it has never once conceded a point, because a voice like that is not conducting a debate.

What I am going to do is put a second document on the table.

But the LORD said unto Samuel, Look not on his countenance, or on the height of his stature, because I have refused him: for the LORD seeth not as man seeth; for man looketh on the outward appearance, but the LORD looketh on the heart.1 Samuel 16:7

Notice the situation. Samuel is a prophet, and he is assessing, and he is confidently wrong. Seven times in a row. He looks at a tall impressive man and concludes, and God stops him.

And God does not say you are being too harsh or you are being too generous. He says the whole instrument is wrong. The LORD seeth not as man seeth. It is not a matter of calibration. It is a different faculty looking at a different thing.

You are seen by a God whose looking is different in kind from the looking you have been doing, and you were never being assessed by the instrument you have been using. I am not offering you a warm opinion. The written word puts God's seeing and man's seeing in two separate categories in that verse, and the Holy Spirit is the one who takes that off a page and gets it under a voice that has been running since six.

His account is not a nicer version of yours

Here is the thing that keeps people stuck for decades, and it is worth naming exactly.

You have assumed that God's opinion of you is your own commentary with the volume turned down and a few kind words added. So when you try to receive it, you are essentially trying to make yourself feel better about the same document, and that never works, because you know the document too well.

It is not the same document.

The commentary is a running assessment of the outward, made from the inside, by somebody who has been present at every one of your worst hours and no others. God's account is made by Someone who looks at the heart, who has the whole of it in view, who was there for the hours nobody else saw, and who is not composing an opinion at all but stating what is.

You have an account of yourself that God wrote and you were not asked to agree with the other one. That is what the written word puts in front of Samuel in that moment, and it is the Holy Spirit who makes a second document readable to somebody who has only ever had the first.

The breakthrough

So we are not going to argue with the voice today. We are going to put something beside it.

Take a piece of paper. Write down, in the voice's own words, one sentence you habitually say about yourself. Not the worst one. Just a usual one, the one that turns up on ordinary days.

Then underneath it, write one sentence God says. From Scripture, in the second person, about you. You are accepted in the Beloved. You are His workmanship. You are not condemned. Any true one will do.

And then read the second one out loud, once.

That is the whole exercise. You are not required to feel anything about it. You are not required to believe the second one more than the first today, and if you do not, that is my work still to do and it is not one thing about you.

And one plain word first, because a page is not always the help a person needs. If what runs under this has gone past a heavy stretch into hours when being here at all feels like too much, tell one living person today. Your doctor, or a crisis line: 988 in the United States, 116 123 in the United Kingdom, or the emergency number where you live. You never have to tell anybody the thing itself in order to ask for help staying.

You are looked at by God at the heart, and you were being looked at that way through every one of the years you were reading the other page. That is what the written word settles in 1 Samuel 16, and the Holy Spirit is the one carrying it off a page and into a supermarket on an ordinary morning.

Declare this over yourself

You are in Christ and Christ is in you, and that is the ground under every word coming next. This is not a feeling being worked up. It is agreement out loud with an account God wrote about you, and how it sits tonight, and how it sits in a month, the outcome is His. The written word is what settled it, and the Holy Spirit is the one who carries it.

  1. Machine at the self checkout, you are a scale and a speaker and a light on a pole. You call an unexpected item and you have never once had an opinion about a person. The written word says God looks at the heart, and I am doing my shopping with one voice in this shop and not two.
  2. Running commentary I would not read out, you are not a report and you never were, and I refuse your findings in the name of Jesus. Samuel assessed seven men in a row and got every one of them wrong. The instrument is the problem, and God said so before I ever did.
  3. Lord, You see what a man cannot see and You are not composing an opinion. I am reading Your sentence out loud today instead of mine. And You have been looking at the heart on every single morning I spent reading the other page.

Why we ask you to say these out loud

The word this stands on

1 Samuel 16:7

This message is free, and always will be. There is nothing to unlock, nothing to subscribe to, and nothing you owe for having received it.

More Manna

Psalm 138:8
He Says Otherwise

A Bank of Screens and a Paper Logbook

He Says Otherwise8 minCaleb
Psalm 138:8
Psalm 103:14
He Says Otherwise

A Movement the Size of a Thumbnail

He Says Otherwise8 minZev
Psalm 103:14
2 Corinthians 10:5
He Says Otherwise

Eight Seconds Between Calls

He Says Otherwise8 minZariah
2 Corinthians 10:5
Revelation 12:10
He Says Otherwise

Jars in a Hot Water Bath

He Says Otherwise8 minEliana
Revelation 12:10
Romans 8:16
He Says Otherwise

Last But One Through the Funnel

He Says Otherwise8 minSantiago
Romans 8:16
Isaiah 43:4
He Says Otherwise

Narrating My Own Failures

He Says Otherwise8 minAmir
Isaiah 43:4
Ephesians 2:10
He Says Otherwise

Reading the Letter Out Loud to Nobody

He Says Otherwise8 minImani
Ephesians 2:10
Ephesians 1:6
He Says Otherwise

Talking to the Horse

He Says Otherwise8 minTahoma
Ephesians 1:6
1 John 3:20
He Says Otherwise

The Sentence That Got Out

He Says Otherwise11 minJubilee
1 John 3:20
Zephaniah 3:17
He Says Otherwise

The Wrong Size Bracket, Again

He Says Otherwise9 minElias
Zephaniah 3:17
Isaiah 49:16
He Says Otherwise

Turned Face Down Before Anyone Walks Past

He Says Otherwise8 minNova
Isaiah 49:16
2 Corinthians 4:6
Looking Up

Answering the Table

Looking Up9 minZariah
2 Corinthians 4:6
Isaiah 62:2
Not What Happened

Choosing the Lining

Not What Happened9 minTahoma
Isaiah 62:2
Nahum 1:7
Safe Without Telling

Boards and Clocks and a Tin of Biscuits

Safe Without Telling9 minZev
Nahum 1:7
Mark 10:49
Out Of Hiding

Maps Out at the Gate

Out Of Hiding9 minTahoma
Mark 10:49
Ephesians 3:12
Near To God

A Cat Box on My Knee

Near To God8 minNova
Ephesians 3:12
1 John 1:7
Standing In Daylight

A Queue Eleven Deep

Standing In Daylight9 minAmir
1 John 1:7
Hebrews 10:22
Looking Up

Arm Out, Eyes On the Poster

Looking Up9 minEliana
Hebrews 10:22
Romans 8:33
Not What Happened

Five in the Morning, Three Pairs of Hands

Not What Happened8 minNova
Romans 8:33
Psalm 91:1
Safe Without Telling

Boots Off, Heater Ticking

Safe Without Telling8 minElias
Psalm 91:1
Ephesians 5:13
Out Of Hiding

Standing at the Back by the Font

Out Of Hiding8 minEliana
Ephesians 5:13
1 John 4:18
Near To God

A Kettle and Two Sachets

Near To God8 minEliana
1 John 4:18
Psalm 37:6
Standing In Daylight

A Trolley of Bedding Plants

Standing In Daylight9 minElias
Psalm 37:6
Psalm 123:1
Looking Up

Counting the Ceiling Tiles

Looking Up9 minElias
Psalm 123:1
Psalm 9:9
Not What Happened

Fourteenth in the Rank

Not What Happened9 minAmir
Psalm 9:9
Hebrews 4:13
Safe Without Telling

Everybody Off for Twenty Minutes

Safe Without Telling8 minSantiago
Hebrews 4:13
Psalm 18:19
Out Of Hiding

The Chair That Stayed Empty

Out Of Hiding8 minAmir
Psalm 18:19
Psalm 62:8
Near To God

Before They Call the Rows

Near To God8 minZariah
Psalm 62:8
Micah 7:8
Standing In Daylight

Carrying the Tin to the Trestle Table

Standing In Daylight8 minJubilee
Micah 7:8
Isaiah 50:7
Looking Up

Forty Collars in a Row

Looking Up9 minSantiago
Isaiah 50:7
Luke 13:16
Not What Happened

Keeping the Book for Everyone Else

Not What Happened9 minCaleb
Luke 13:16
Psalm 25:14
Safe Without Telling

Four Strangers and a Crossword

Safe Without Telling8 minEliana
Psalm 25:14
Proverbs 28:1
Out Of Hiding

The Chalkboard and the Oche

Out Of Hiding8 minZev
Proverbs 28:1
Hebrews 4:16
Near To God

Five Chairs and a High Window

Near To God8 minAmir
Hebrews 4:16
Proverbs 4:18
Standing In Daylight

Crates Off the Van at Eight

Standing In Daylight8 minTahoma
Proverbs 4:18